The Iran Fiasco

Download PDF

For two or three years now, I’ve defined the dynamics of our time as:

  • The perpetuation of the U.S. Forever War
  • The persistent growth of government debt
  • The monopolization of commerce and the resulting income and wealth disparity
  • The end of the unipolar, post-war world order
  • The relentless march of technology and the subversion of privacy

Of course, President Trump’s campaign platform advertised the opposite, which brought him into power on a landslide. He was going to be the “peace president” and he was going to bring to a grinding halt the fiscal recklessness his predecessors had embraced. Yet, here we are. As everyone can see, the Trump presidency is characterized by exactly what Donald Trump denied he’d ever do: unprovoked foreign intervention to initiate changes in regimes not aligned with American interests, at a cost that seriously undermines prudent and sustainable fiscal practices, and leaves America’s military in greater strategic overreach than has been the case in years. Personally, I think the Iran intervention is the most imprudent American enterprise in decades, rivalling such tragic missteps as Vietnam and Iraq. And why would the U.S. engage in such a misguided endeavour?

There are two simple reasons. The principal one is that State Department doctrine has for years been that America will not tolerate a rival: militarily, economically or ideologically. China has for years been the principal threat to the U.S.-led unipolar world order and Washington’s current view is that American control of the world’s energy supplies will significantly slow China’s march forward.

The second rationale is that Israel’s objectives are not only aligned with America’s, but that the Netanyahu government’s aspirations will bolster U.S. dominance of the Middle East. I believe both judgments are profoundly faulty.

Let me share three quotes and explain why I think they are relevant to the current geopolitical situation:

“God created war so Americans would learn Geography” – Mark Twain

(Listening to the simple-minded and blatantly ignorant comments by neo-conservative U.S. Senators like Lindsay Graham or Ted Cruz, Secretary of War Peter Hegseth or Secretary of State Marco Rubio, reminded me of this quote).

“The first casualty, when war comes, is truth.” – Aeschylus

(This quote has been mistakenly attributed to more modern figures like Hiram Johnson or Winston Churchill. But the habit of governments to distort, hide, or invent information to control public opinion, demonize the enemy, and justify military actions goes back to ancient Greek times).

“America is an oil company with an army.” – George Carlin

(From the U.S. energy-related seizures and sanctions of the past few years to the recent interventions in Venezuela and now Iran, the theme persists. America’s wars have never been about values; they’ve been about resources and money).

So what can we learn from America’s latest actions? To begin with, the economic and social consequences that arise from decades of unsustainable policies will now be further enhanced by geopolitics. Yes, the economics chaos unleashed by the Trump tariff theatrics is very much alive, but the potential disruptions caused by project Iran are even greater. And yes, the social backlash to years of misguided European and American policies is growing, but the expressions of discontent will change, as exploding energy prices and their impact on numerous other costs will further undermine standards of living.

Perhaps most importantly, trust in the United States has now eroded to the point where few nations will be willing to stay invested in the Washington-led unipolar model. America’s allies are in retreat, seeking new alliances—in trade, militarily and monetarily. To be sure, the adjustments will unfold gradually; after all, the U.S. did lead the Western world for eight decades.

A few days ago in a speech to the Australian parliament, Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney referred to the current situation as a “breakdown in the established global order”. Other leaders have said the same, but Carney’s words captured the current sentiment best.

What we’re experiencing is just that—a breakdown in the established world order. Europe, Canada and Mexico have for some time been bewildered by President Trump’s confrontational and self-serving style. Both on the trade and military fronts, U.S. actions have made it not just necessary, but also advantageous to distance themselves.

The Iran action is not only messing up relationships with former allies and friends but also alienating a number of Middle Eastern players. Apart from facing serious declines in export revenues, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Bahrain, Oman, Qatar and others are disgusted with America’s manifest choice of Israel as the future dominant force in the region. That will have massive implications for many years to come. It also brings China and Russia even closer together, while alienating major players like India.

The bottom line looks something like this:

  • Trump’s crew hasn’t realized it yet, but Iran does not have to win the war. Enduring it and keeping energy shipments in peril will be entirely sufficient to weaken the U.S. and Israel.
  • What Netanyahu’s team is missing is that the U.S. political landscape is starting to shift. Not only are American citizens fed up with their endless war losses, but to have so many of the Pentagon’s recent decisions influenced or even manipulated by Israel is equally difficult to stomach. The president’s claim that “our objective is to defend the American people by eliminating imminent threats from the Iranian regime” is proving to be unsaleable at home.
  • Donald Trump’s “America First” narrative is not compatible with foreign adventurism paid for by U.S. consumers. Effectively, that means that Trump’s dominance over the country’s political structure may be near its end. Considering the president’s addiction to power, that makes the coming days and weeks particularly dangerous.

Market Implications

Financial markets hate uncertainty. Gold has easily recovered above the US$5,000 level, while oil prices have exploded. And elevated energy costs will affect countless other areas, from manufacturing and transportation costs to chemical and food production. If the situation persists, the Covid-era “supply-chain disruptions” will revisit us within days.

The official consumer price index in the U.S. is 2.8% above last year’s level, but no one believes that. Similar distortions to reality are in play in most of the EU, in Britain, Canada and many other developed and emerging economies. Decades of adjustments to the calculation method for inflation have got us to this point.

The most relevant question is how the Federal Reserve and other central banks will address a situation where inflation is on the rise again, while employment statistics are weakening. In the current environment of stagflation, the prospect of further interest rate relief is diminishing.

And all along, the central banks’ mandate is further complicated by persistent overspending by governments. Much attention will be focused on the U.S., a significant part of whose debt has historically been financed by foreigners. Given America’s confrontational style and its “sanctions and seizures” habit,

the odds are high that the Treasury’s weekly bond auctions will face growing challenges.

The most likely outcome is that the Federal Reserve will revert to aggressive quantitative easing—in effect purchasing the government’s bonds with newly created money. A profoundly imprudent practice, to be sure, but one that will allow continued excesses in spending, obviously at tomorrow’s expense. The eventual consequences: inflation and currency depreciation.

Portfolio Comments

Our model portfolio continues to hold up well. While our robust gold position boosted 2025 results, our bets on energy and commodities plays have been contributing to outperformance so far this year. Also of help has been our exposure to some of the more defensive plays, particularly in the utilities space.

Within our stock portfolio, we pay particular attention to liquidity, balance sheet strength and cash flow generation. The main theme for equities: the broad market looks vulnerable, so sector and stock selection are of enormous importance.

Let me also address a couple of subjects that keep coming up in comments and questions we receive from readers. Gold, copper and Bitcoin seem to be particularly topical.

“You’ve been consistently right on gold for a long time. What are your thoughts now?”

Gold had a meaningful correction after reaching its all-time high of over $5,500, dipping all the way down to $4,700. However, in the context of a virtual doubling in the metal’s price in one year, some profit-taking was overdue.

Impressively, gold has rebounded sharply since it’s early February lows, easily crossing back into the $5,000/$5,400 range. What leaves me confident that gold has further upside is continued demand from central banks and investors. An interesting development in the latter category is the emergence of gold-backed stablecoins. Tether, the largest of these, now holds roughly US$23 billion in gold, more than the central banks of Australia, the United Arab Emirates, Qatar or South Korea. Not yet a game-changer, but something to keep an eye on.

We continue to hold 14% of total assets in physical bullion, and an additional 2.5% in gold mining equities.

“With economic prospects weakening, are you still bullish copper?”

Yes we are. Copper has appreciated from just over $4 in early 2025 to close to $6, yet we think it can rise further. With the building of data centers making up a major portion of the next two or three years’ economic activity, conducting metals like copper will be in high demand. Yet supplies remain tight and production costs will continue to rise. By the way, we harbor similar hopes for uranium, which continues to be part of our portfolio.

“You mentioned Bitcoin a few times, but your model portfolio never reflected more than minimal holdings.”

That’s correct. I’ve struggled to understand crypto currencies for some time and decided that we’d dabble with a 1%-2% trading position—always in Bitcoin ETFs, which seem to me the most practical. While those positions have generated good returns, the unpredictability of the crypto space has left me stunned. For now, I’ve given up, much preferring gold, which has once again proven itself as a potent portfolio stabilizer.

Would I be a seller of Bitcoin after its spectacular crash from $100,000 to the $62,000/72,000 range, if I held any? No, but I’d probably lighten up on any significant recovery.

All in all, our investment approach has consistently produced strong returns, which is why we see no reason to make any changes. Even so, given the multitude of current uncertainties, we are reassessing our strategy continuously. In the coming days, watch for energy prices and statements regarding Iran (no matter how manipulated they are) to trigger volatility.

Best regards,

Peter Cavelti